The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutItem 3 - 907 Washington Avenue OSHKOSH LANDMARKS COMMISSION TO: Landmarks Commission FROM: Steven Wiley, Staff Liaison DATE: July 1yt, 2019 SUBJECT: Item 3: 907 Washington Avenue Tax Credit Project—Terry Laib -Discussion 1.) Initiated by: Terry Laib This property is a contributing structure in the Washington Avenue Historic District and was approved for homeowner tax credits. Mr. Laib is working on the project as the contractor and approached staff about the project and placing it on the agenda. 2.) Is the item related to an Historic District/contributing, listed individually, Landmarked or eligible? This property is part of the Washington Avenue Historic District and is a contributing structure designed by William Waters. 2a.) Does item conform with all Local, State, or other Ordinances, Statutes? This project has several conditions that it must meet as a tax credit project. The Wisconsin Historical Society has already sent these conditions to the property owner and Mr. Laib had these conditions also. 2b.) Has the State Historical Society been notified or involved? Yes—the State has been involved and State architect Mark Buechel was involved with the approval process. 2c.)Are other organizations or entities involved? No. 3.) Are Historic Tax Credits applicable for this item? Yes—it is a tax credit project. 4.) Does this pertain to municipally-owned structures? No. The house is a privately-owned residential property. 5.) What is the Commission priority #for this item? Ongoing projects and property owners that approach the Commission for input are a top priority of the Commission,along with other ongoing tasks. 5a.) Does the Commission have enough information for action(s)? The Commission should have enough information and there is no action the Commission would have to take. Under the historic preservation ordinance the Commission does not review tax credit projects since the State already handles this. If you are unable to attend this meeting,it is important to notify Steven Wiley (920-236-5062)in case a quorum cannot be attained. OSHKOSH LANDMARKS COMMISSION Discussion Considerations 1.) More research or follow up on Item? No. Once the project is complete the appropriate paperwork and images must be submitted to the state. 2.) Evidence of"original"? Restore to what time period? Mr. Laib did research and drawings which he sent to the state and the Wisconsin Historical Society reviewed them. 3.) Replacement Materials: accepted by State Historical society? See the conditions assigned in the approval. 4.) Consideration of`undo hardship on ownersT Funding sources? Owners will be paying for the project. 5.) Take actions? Per the historic preservation ordinance no action is necessary. 6.) Follow up? None at this time. If you are unable to attend this meeting,it is important to notify Steven Wiley (920-236-5062)in case a quorum cannot be attained. City;; P O Bo)i Of Oshkosh, WI 54903 s h s Phone: (920)236 Fax: (920)236 www.ci.oshkosh Roofing, Siding & Windows Permit Project 9 Address � 1 Applicant ❑ Owner v Contractor ❑ Tenant ;-�❑ Other(describe) Owner/ Name S v e- T iJ v� Ci t2 G �JGt�`i ( Gt i� 5 Phone Tenant Address Ca ll h6l Email Contractor Company Name OP--, Phone .1 7 Contact_T L IC LGC ` Email Address q10 ,'"a,,4� RUV�it�cGt State Credential#'s -1 0 U , D 6 - d b ?�y 0 U 3-3 Dwelling Contractor Qualifier# Dwelling Contractor# Building Contractor Registrati( Permit Type V Residential ❑ Commercial Location t� House ❑ House & Garage ❑ Commercial Building ❑ Accessory Structure Project Roofing: Siding: Windows: Information Tear off all layers: Current Siding Material: Number of Windows: # X Yes ❑No ❑ Vinyl Z Wood ❑ Steel ❑Concrete Window Type: ❑ New Opening Replace roof decking: ❑ Asphalt ❑ Stucco ❑ Other p g ❑ Yes ❑No New Siding Material: Replacement Same Size&Locatic ❑Vinyl p Wood ❑ Steel ❑ Concrete ❑Asphalt ❑ Stucco ❑ Other Project Description t{�.^ 1`o��.� CJv G 4v r L - t Gw n v'r r 1C �0 l& c� ;-or el ac-1 ),4q s r, 13a cl( C� GI �1 �� Vy I'4 0 Y'e�Ge V' yvw 0'r it 6� Z— h Gk' ��iJ v2.1 l 1 �J�J i ►�r l�'GX . I? Get it GC l��"t c� �Q� P�X Mechanical Separate permits will be obtained for the following: Permits Electrical by ll76��f-�t 5 Plumbing by/0P Ci i`�� Heating by k,04,6f �U N1 S Value Of Job ,(� j (Value for materials&labor is req.to ensure consistency in accessing permit fees for all applic Payment by: ❑ Check # ❑ Cash ❑ Fee Account ❑ Credit/Debit Card (office or online I certify the above information is complete and accurate. Any deviations from the above submitted information may require additional p to be obtained. I acknowledge and agree to these terns. 1�Tnma tPlPaca nrint) I7AtP.' ZENSIVE SURVEY FORr1 Historic Preservation Division State Historical Society of Wisconsin City, village or Town: 7Tf::7 Surveyor: v:HNTB BO z Acreage: °' ^ t s h k O S h Legal Description: Street Address: ®. 'J- :3 W a s h i n t O n Current owner: rrent Name b Use: o Current Owner's Address: D Roll No. O Special Features Not visible In Photographs: z r hive No. • �, �� . ® Cr side Orient. ��_ ..._ (Z)No - Interior visited? O Yes Source � Source Previous Owners Dates Uses c Original Name 4 Use: R. J . Weisbrod House source Dates of Construction -Iteration A/B porch pot 1908 C. 1870 ' s w'Source m Architect and/or builder: Historical Significance Architectural Significance Assoc. with laves of significant persons Represents work of a master Assoc. with significant historical events R ossesses high artistic values Assoc. with development of a locality 0 apresents a type, period, or method of construction Ussoc. a visual landmark in the area ®None O None - ,her: C Historical Statement: w ro atatement: rchitectural S z R.J . Weisbrod was originally a The window treatment on this Italian- furniture dealer and undertaker. - ate house is particularly fine. The In the 1880 ' s he became the chief building is sheathed in clapboards up of police. According to city o to the head of the second story window directories the Weisbrod resi - above that a band of vertical boards , dence was located at this addressN terminating in cusps , continue around prior to 1876 , but a.fter 1868. (A) a the house . This is one of the most rn creative Italianate designs in terms of details , however , a more modern porch addition detracts from the desig to some extent. Representation in Previous Surveys Sources of Information (Reference to Above O WS O NAER 0 WIHP O NM ®landmark o e Oshkosh C i t D i r e c t o r i es 1 8 6 8® ,�(Condition d excellent ®good O fair ®^oor S District: Washin ton Ave. Historic pivotal 0 contributing O non-contributing � w initials: D S date: 5/l /8 1 _ 0-pinion of National Register Elig�Lbility 10 eligible O not eligible O unimOw' \ -®national O state local initials: HP-02-17 21 i WISCONSI `u �'n�P �, Kx STORICAL tars°o�Y r T Y . ............... ....... HISTORIC HOMEOWNER'S INCOME TAX CREDIT APPLICATION PART 2— DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED WORK 1. PROPERTY ADDRESS Street 907 Washington Avenue 54901 City Oshkosh, Wi. CountyWlnnebago* ZIP 2. OWNER'S NAME Susan Tatum and David Beardsley Street 663 Cayuga Drive „r 407 493-8916 City Winter Springs Stated' ZIP 32708 Telephone (days)__.-) Email address suetatum@me.com 3. PROJECT CONTACT Terry Laib 920 379-9773 Email addressTlaib@Laibrestoration.com Telephone(days)_1 4. OWNER'S CERTIFICATION I hereby attest that the information I have provided is,to the best of my knowledge, correct and that I own the property described above. I understand that the falsification of factual representations in the application maybe subject to criminal sanctions. I further agree to submit the Request for Certification of Completed Work within 30 days of the date_of completion of work or face forfeiture of any tax credit claimed for this project. �- • DATE SIGNATURE OF OWNER � - - SEND COMPLETED APPLICATIONS TO State Historic Preservation Office Wisconsin Historical Society—Room 312 816 State Street, Madison,WI 53706 STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE USE ONLY WHS PROJECT NO. The State Historic Preservation Office has reviewed this application for the above name property and has determined that: _ the property is historic property and the rehabilitation as described meets the"Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation." This is a preliminary determination only. Final certification can be issued only after work has been completed and a Request for !' Certification of Completed Work has been approved, the property is historic property and the rehabilitation will meetah certif certification ocanhbel issued only afterdwork has been Rehabilitation" hed ncompleted and conditions are met. This is a preliminary determination only. Request for Certification of CompietA . ti Work has been approved. j 4/fd Date For Jim Ura `ag t'e Hittori Preservation Officer i 1 NON-CERTIFICATION _ THE OWNER MAY NOT CLAIM THE TAX CREDIT. The rehabilitation is not consistent with the historic character of the property and that the for reasons given in the project does not meet the"Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation" e attached materials. THE OWNER MAY NOT CLAIM THE TAX CREDIT. The property has not been determined to be historic property for purposes of this program. Date I For Jim Draeger, State Historic Preservation officer V17 � 3C0 NOINt NN APR 0 2A�1 � O/ T� � -T0�I�� —'' — )r _____ 1 11STONCHOkXEOW&[�� 0�[ A`CF-EDIT A:,PUCATON �� .�� ~�� ' �~^ ~~~~ ^^^~~ ~ SIGNIFICANCE ��V�� « "°�� « 1' PROPERTY ADDRESS Street S87 Washington AV-mUa Ci Oshkosh, VVi 0un Winnebago _Z| 54901 Listed individually in the State Register or National Register. COMPLETE THIS PAGE{)�LY LISTING NAME Located (naState Register orNational Register historic distric1. COMPLETE THIS PAGE ONLY ^--' Washington Avenue Historic District NAME OF HISTORIC DISTRICT � PRELIMINARY CERTIFICATION Not listed in State Register orNational, Register of iocated in a State Register | | or National Register historic district-COMPLETE BOTH PAGES 2. OWNERS. 0AK8 GuGaOTatuOnaOdDavidBnanda\y G68 (�ayugaOhva Stree - city Winter GPrings State F| | 32708 Telephone (days)407 498'8916 ouotaturnV�meConn En1ai|address � 3. PROJECT CONTACT Terry Laib Email address 7laib@ |eibreoto'aton.com Telephone (days) 820 37g'S773_________ 4. PHOTOGRAPHS Please enclose photographs of the exterior of the building to be rehabilitated. Photos should be in color, at least 4"x 6",commercially printed and clearly show all sides of the building. 5. OWNER'S CERTIFICATION I hereby attest that the information I have provided is,to the best of my knowledge, correct and that /own the property described above. | understand that the falsification Uf factual representations in the application may be subject to criminal sancLLons_ SIGNATURE OF OWNER DATE SEND COMPLETED APPLICATION'S TO State Historic Preservation Office Wisconsin Historical Society-Room 312 G16 State Street, kViadison,VV| 53706 The State Historic Preservation Office has reviewed this application and has determined that: the property is listed Ili the State Register of Historic Places or National Register of Historic Places and is historic property for purposes of the Historic Homeowner's Income Tax Credit- the property contributes to the above-nar-ried State Kegister or ,iationai Register historic district and is historic property for purposes of the Historic Homeowner's Income Tax Credit. the property appears to meet the State Register or National Register Criteria for Evaluation and,therefore is determined to be historic property for purposes of the Historic Homeowner's Income Tax Credit. NON-CERTIFICATION: the property is not listed in the State register of Historic Places or National Register of Historic Places,is not a contributing element to a State Register historic district or National Register historic district,and does not appear to meet the State Register or National Register Criteria for Evajdation;therefore.the property is not a historic property for purposes of the Historic Homeowner's Income Tax Gfecli.. olh ForJ Date STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE USE ONLY alMS. ROJECr Mays ay WISCONSIN HISTORICAL S O C I E T Y ASSIGNED PROJECT CONDITIONS Contractor Copy PROPERTY NAME: R.J. Weisbrod House PROJECT NUMBER: WI190108, WI190109, WI190110, WI190111, WI190112, WI190113, WI190114 907 Washington Avenue Oshkosh In order for your project to be approved for income tax credits the following conditions must be met. A second copy of these conditions are being provided for your contractor's use. It is the homeowner's responsibility that all conditions are met. Failure to meet these conditions results in project denial. 1. It is unclear if any costs related to the rear porch are included in the eligible expenses. The rear porch has no documentation to verify how it appeared therefore no work related to the reconstruction can be eligible since it is considered conjecture. The sketch for the front porch is marginal not knowing when it was produced, however we will allow it as evidence for reconstruction of the front porch. It cannot be assumed the rear porch matched the front porch, rear porches were often simplified. 2. For the front porch reconstruction to be eligible it must exactly match the historic, even minor modifications can render the work ineligible so please accurately recreate the porch in size, design, and details. 3. The package is unclear,The porch floor should be a tongue and groove floor not spaced boards. 4. All exterior wood, repaired, replaced or new must be painted or stained with a solid body 100% opaque stain. The use of transparent or semitransparent finishes on exterior wood is prohibited. 5. The use of lowEIl glass in any storm window or the select new windows or doors is not approved. ideally the glass is clear to match the historic, however a single coat of lowE can be considered�s�long as the visible light transmittance is 72% or greater. off fffR, /9 Mark Buechel for Jim Draeger, State Historic Preservation Officer DATE Collecting,Preserving and Sharing Stories Since 1846 816 State Street Madison,Wisconsin 53706 E wisconsinhistory.org 14t5TORY WISCONSIN May 2,2019 HISTORICAL S O C I� E 'T 'Y Susan Tatum& David Beardsly 663 Cayuga Drive Oshkosh, WI 32708 Re: Historic Preservation Certification Application Project Number W1190108,WI190109, W1190110, W1190111,W1190112, WI190113, W1190114 Reviewed: Conditionally Approved Dear Susan Tatum & David Beardsly, On 2019-04-08,the Division of Historic Preservation received a Historic Preservation Certification Application for your property at 907 Washington Avenue in Oshkosh. The application was for over $192K, state statute prohibits more than $1 OK in tax credits per project so as submitted you forfeit all credits on work in excess of$40K. We took the liberty of breaking the project up into 7 smaller projects so you can maximize your available credit. Please pay attention as to what is on each project when submitting the final certification costs. Enclosed is a copy of the signed Part 1 applications indicating your house has been determined to be a historic property for purposes of this program. We have reviewed the Part 2 applications and determined the proposed project will meet the"Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation"if the conditions on the following page are met. Enclosed is a copy of the signed Part 2 application. If questions arise during your project,we have many new articles about maintaining and preserving historic buildings that you may find useful: www wisconsinhistoi org/preserve-your-building When all work is completed,the project must be closed out in order to claim/retain tax credits. 1. Take photographs of the overall appearance of the house(from all four sides), as well as detailed "after" shots of the specific work that you have carried out. These photos should be printed in color and of a high resolution. 2. Send the photos to us along with the Request for Certification of Completed Work(attached). 3. A signed Certification of Completed Work will be required by the Department of Revenue to claim the tax credits. If you have any questions I can be reached by mail at the Wisconsin Historical Society, by telephone at 608/264-6491, by fax at 608/264-6504, or by e-mail at mark buechel@wisconsinhistory.org. Please take our 3 minute customer service survey. Your feedback is important to us— http://bit.ly/SHPOsurvey. Sincerely Mark T. Buechel, AIA Senior Preservation Architect Collecting, 'reserving and Sharing Stories Since 1846 816 State Street Madison,Wisconsin 53706 �2T wisconsinhistory.org HI `pfJRICA.L HISTORIC HOMEOWNER'S NCUIqi��PRAX C D1SEI}P�fJRICN PART 2- DESCRI T!ON INSTRUCTIONS Describe each item of your project and the materials and methods you propose to 7. Exterior Foundation: original stone foundation has been c as is. with Cunnite which is not removable without damage original stone and mortar so we plan to leave that ed ceiling. ndow Front por ont ch : remove front porch back to original fir deck a new front posh per draw'ng!Ev d wall, n enceofrthe wall and door with sidelights. Reuse original stone piers an reframe original porch footprint shown in photo. edar. Floor to All millwork for restored porch toQ clear leaepi e or cfactory painted clear fir 1X4 t and g. Roof to be EPDM ;edge metal t Y Exisitng entry door to be restored to be retained and mist has been damaged. Existing original siding on porch Above porch, decorative brakets and sawn ornamentation to be restore opposite facing north to be restored to match original windows exactly the east facing ng tall narorowi window at the opp sent to Window g the bedroom wall.The narrow west facing window to matchY end of the hall. be doubtehung single glazed ploughed for ropes Casingdetail on both windows to match original exactly;sash to and balances. Interior casing, stool and aprons to match original. historic photos st of is elevation. Bac k addition to be removed entirely and new back porch pereredred lumbero deck to be fir, hanidra Ishbalusters to be piers to be salvage limestone blocks,deck to be framed cedar. Ceiling to be beaded and roof to be EPDM . Second floor doors to be Marvin French doors. Cut sheets attached s designed to match the daylight opening the same as Furnish and install 15 Marvin wood combination storm window the wood storms. Cut sheet attached. Restore exterior window casings on 19 openings to include new drip caps and repairs to all decayed or missing elements. with#1 Replacing 2800 lineal feet of cracked, cupped bead on sougth elevation. ar 1�2 X 6" bevel cedar siding Install two 12'outside corners with matching center Replace 20'of skirt and water table on south elevation. Restore gable fascia and sawn ornamentation on east,west and north gables using dutchman repair and epoxies as needed. Entire house to be primed and painted. Interior: 2nd floor includes removing 1960'eb bathroom, onteastgside�repair Doren south bedroomd by the bath dition. Adding master bath with hallway p p stac 1 st floor remodeling includes gur dryer in tting and installing new bathroomin he kitchen plus one new sink base)and top tomatch adjoining closet.We are retaining the existing c original. ondenser on east side of house with line se Air conditioning for 2nd floor only with Bryant air handler in attic, c behind downspout. 8'round ceiling diffusers. SEND COMPLETED APPLICATIONS TO State Historic Preservation Office Wisconsin Historical Society—Room 312 816 State Street Madison,WI 53706 410 Fast Murdock Avenue Oshkosh,Wisconsin 54901 Telephone 920.233-7026 LA Fax 920-233-4IB RESTORATION, INC. 847 Historic Building Consultation 'Z J4 d U I ri FRONT PORCH NORTH -"' L•, 410 East Murdock Avenue Oshkosh,Wisconsin 54-901 LAI.B- Telephone 920.233 7026 I` RESTORATION,INC. Fax 9?0�233.484? _ - Historic Building Consultation ij- t Lr'��{•l'• { EL -id t r A -- • f .. ....,. 1lfy :{ r 11 •, ! i 'Y" i y .t ,. i I I i FRONT .PORCH ..- WEST i i � ,, �` ,� r ,. I i ! `� t �.r � � �' f .r.�� 1 1 �`,��,!w7 � �( ; ` ` �? _ i� ' i- i "� -. _ �t\. 1 f � sL��..� i ,� —_� �_ ': _ f i ` �_ j I 4 i � s � i _�. - s - — ., i �: ,, . �� ., .. � _ _\ fj _.____�._v�._ _. _. _.-_. �_ � , F ___ ___..- —._. -_—___._—_a� f � _._ ._ __ __. ` ��_--_---- ---- __ -- --- ` ,i � _ (, _ ( �F � __ .� ,� � ' � � i � f __ f i, � �. �. ___ -- _ -_ E ' r - -_- _ — — ��- --- __ —_ — ; _ __. _ f - � _ — — c ,-'� •� Jr' � .. _ __r � ... ,_ _ , _. ' �. �.-�_ _ .., �` � �\ ,� k. _ „< \III.;� J `�� _ �i�-�.? � 'l_t•''. l l� l� Z � 't � � �. �f J /' _ � 'Vr 1 - -�1," �t?� ��if t � �y��rf�' `� .� t. - t 1 , J t b tt _F a 410 East Murdock Avenue d Oshkosh,Wisconsin 54901 Telephone 920.233.7026 E ►ESTORATION, INC. Fax 920.233.4847 -: Historic Building Consultation i ! 111 { t ' i < 1 , t f t 4 : i t y j 1 r {_ _ 'mob., _ _ , it it 17 t _ U- M I ! I i{ Ij4t �• 14 i 1 i i i t ------------------ r-777-�U -31 V3 AL 74 "k '7 � at N Ys IQ