HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 3 0SHI CAS
LANDMARKS
COMMISSION
TO: Landmarks Commission
FROM: Steven Wiley, Staff Liaison
DATE: February 6111, 2018
SUBJECT: Item 3: 434 Church Avenue Proposed Work
1.) Initiated by: Steven Wiley, staff liaison, Landmarks Commission
a.) The item is within the purview of the Commission because it involves rehab work
and potential alterations to the exterior materials of a contributing structure in the
Irving-Church Historic District. The Inspections Services Division issued orders to
correct the peeling paint on some of the dormers on this property. The owner and
contractor originally wanted to wrap the dormers in aluminum trim. The owner has
discussed some of the proposed work with staff and was planning to come to the
Landmarks meeting in February to discuss with the Commission.
2.) Is the item related to an Historic District/contributing, listed individually, Landmarked
or eligible?
Yes—the property at 434 Church is a contributing structure.
2a.)Does item conform with all Local, State, or other Ordinances, Statutes?
The original work proposed could conflict with the local ordinance. It could conflict
with state and national standards if the owner was applying for tax credits.
2b.) Has the State Historical Society been notified or involved?
No
2c.)Are other organizations or entities involved?
Yes—City Inspections has orders on the property to scrape and repaint the areas that
are peeling. Inspections has asked that the owner attend the February Landmarks
meeting to avoid further enforcement action at this time.
3.) Are Historic Tax Credits applicable for this item?
Tax credits likely would not apply with the current state the property is in(having
undergone many alterations over time).
4.) Is this a municipally-owned structure?
No. The property is privately owned.
5.) What is the Commission priority #for this item?
Responding to historic project submittals is an ongoing task so a number 1 priority
for the Commission.
If you are unable to attend this meeting,it is important to notify Steven Wiley
(920-236-5062)in case a quorum cannot be attained.
0SHIWS
LANDMARKS
COMMISSION
5a.)Does the Commission have enough information for action(s)?
The Commission should have enough information for making a recommendation
after discussing with the applicant.
Discussion Considerations
1.) More research or follow up on Item?
Yes-staff would work with the applicant depending on what route the applicant
wants to take in conducting work on the property.
2.) Evidence of "original"? Restore to what time period?
3.) Replacement Materials: accepted by State Historical society?
4.) Consideration of`undo hardship on owners?' Funding sources?
5.) Take actions?
6.) Follow up?
I
µ�
✓ "/ � J�� I��/ ��/�/!/�f�J��VIA i� y
If you are unable to attend this meeting,it is important to notify Steven Wiley
(920-236-5062)in case a quorum cannot be attained.
i
/
/
i
i
/
/
/
/
f
/ /
t
user pue s oomglJ!ON paaluielja �apnpui guip!s al,egs ion spaeoq aldLueS
*uns pue ain4stow of ainsodxa
wo.al spjeoq reul8lio loamid of elosei uunuunle alAls u e.a'poom a Om el se) poo h,lle dej
' ulps alAls alegs a !sodwiioa aaa}-a:)ueualulewl a ql!m a:e1dai pine Suipis alegs jepao ,3AOWa,8
rye odo d 'aAV 43j ny: V Ett
Y
i r
i I m r � F i/ // ,waiiui���✓ /
,