HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem VIElementMax. ScoreOshkosh
2016
Scores*
Oshkosh
2017 Goals*
Oshkosh
2018 Goals*
2 2
1 1
3 0
10 0
3 CLARIFY
1 0
5 N/A
5 N/A
5 N/A
3 3
3 N/A
5 5
5 5
10 10
Sustainability Strategies Scoresheet
(Also known as Appendix 3 of GTLC Charter, Last Revised 02-08-2016 by Rick Eilertson)
Eliminate parking minimums from non-residential districts.
League of American Bicyclists certification. (Bronze 5, Silver 7, Platinum 10)
Transportation demand management strategies aim to reduce GHG emissions and VMT by influencing change in individual behavior.
These strategies encourage walking, bicycling, and transit as modes of transportation within a community and seek to curb the
number and length of trips by vehicle.
Require large employers seeking rezoning to set a price signal (cash-out or charge).
Employer-Based Programs
Require large employers seeking rezoning to provide subsidized transit.
Require large employers seeking rezoning to provide a TDM plan that would reduce trips by 20 percent over business as usual.
Set standards for placement and number (as function of intensity of use) for bike parking spaces.
Set parking maximums at X per square feet for office and retail uses.
Transportation system management strategies aim to reduce GHG emissions and VMT by improving the overall performance of a
transportation system. These strategies improve existing infrastructure, introduce new technology, and plan for the future of the
system.
Commuter bike routes identified and cleared.
Require bike parking for all new non-residential and multifamily uses.
Scheduled transit service at basic level (hour peak service within half-mile of 50 percent of addresses).
Bicycle and Pedestrian Programs/Projects
T
R
A
N
S
P
O
R
T
A
T
I
O
N
TRANSPORTATION DEMAND MANAGEMENT:
Funded and operating SRTS program (or functional equivalent) covering at least 10 percent of students.
Scheduled transit service at enhanced level (half-hour peak service within 75 percent of addresses).
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM MANAGEMENT
Track VMT or traffic counts and report on efforts at reduction (including those on this list).
Traffic Volume
Conduct annual survey of students' mode of transport to school.
This Sustainability Strategies Scoresheet is provided for member communities to track sustainability management strategies in
transportation, energy, land use, water, waste, and health. This scoresheet is intended to be dynamic and flexible. In the spirit of
continuous improvement toward superior environmental performance, suggested revisions to this scoresheet are always encouraged.
I:\Planning\Sustainability Advisory Brd\2018\Meeting Packet Info\03-05-18\GTLC_Scoresheet_Filled Out Page 1 of 8
ElementMax. ScoreOshkosh
2016
Scores*
Oshkosh
2017 Goals*
Oshkosh
2018 Goals*
Sustainability Strategies Scoresheet
(Also known as Appendix 3 of GTLC Charter, Last Revised 02-08-2016 by Rick Eilertson)
3 3
5 N/A
5 N/A
5 5
5 5
3 5
1 0
2 N/A
2 N/A
5 N/A
5 5
1 1
1 N/A
10 N/A
5 5
5 0
8 0
5 5
8 0
L
A
N
D
U
S
E
Identify four-lane roadways with fewer than 20,000 vehicles per day (AADT) and evalute them for "road diets" with bike lanes or on-
street parking
Electric Vehicles
Ban idling (more than 5 minutes) with local government vehicles.
Ban idling (more than 5 minutes) community-wide.
ZONING AND DEVELOPMENT
Zoning for office and retail districts permits floor-area ratio > 1, on average.
Calculate lane-miles per capita for arterials and collectors, and show reductions
Develop and fully fund comprehensive maintenance program for existing roads.
Preservation and Improvement
Charge impact fees for new roads.
Prepare a plan identifying disconnections in bike and pedestrian networks, prioritizing fixes and identifying potential funding sources
for the most important projects.
Any proposal to add lanes to a two-lane roadway shall be evaluated for a center turn lane, the preferred option over an expansion
to four lanes.
Vehicle Idling
Zoning code includes mixed use districts
NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
Zoning for office and retail districts requires floor-area ratio > 1, on average.
Mixed-use language from Smart Code TBA.
Measure Walkscore at 10 random residential addresses per Census tract, compute average, and improve upon overall score
Identify priority areas for infill development, including those eligible for brownfields funding.
Walkscore
TR
A
N
S
P
O
R
T
A
T
I
O
N
Allow NEVs on appropriate roadways.
Provide public charging stations
Zoning
Adopt traditional neighborhood design ordinance (If population is less than 12,500)
Create land bank to acquire and assemble priority infill sites
Zoning and development strategies work toward improving the overall environmental, economic, and social health of a community
by promoting mixed-use and infill development, walkable neighborhoods, and an overall sustainable lifestyle.
Infill Development
Develop an inventory of known contaminated properties for reuse planning, with possible GIS application
I:\Planning\Sustainability Advisory Brd\2018\Meeting Packet Info\03-05-18\GTLC_Scoresheet_Filled Out Page 2 of 8
ElementMax. ScoreOshkosh
2016
Scores*
Oshkosh
2017 Goals*
Oshkosh
2018 Goals*
Sustainability Strategies Scoresheet
(Also known as Appendix 3 of GTLC Charter, Last Revised 02-08-2016 by Rick Eilertson)
3 N/A
4 4
2 2
2 2
2 2
2 N/A
2 N/A
10 N/A
5 N/A
6 N/A
1 N/A
10 N/A
4 4
1 N/A
5 N/A
3 N/A
3 N/A
L
A
N
D
U
S
E Adopt tree preservation ordinance per GTLC standards.
Canopy
Work with local utilities to calculate total electricity and natural gas consumption annually, beginning with the fifth year before
entering the program.
Require trees to be planted in all new developments
Vegetation Management
Adopt Residential Energy Conservation Ordinance (time-of-sale certification and upgrades).
Set a tree canopy goal and develop a management plan to achieve it
Community Energy Use Policies
Watt meters available to the public
Establish 75-foot natural vegetation zone by surface water.
Certification as Tree City USA
Reduce motor fuels use for non-transit activities --
Public properties and rights of way mown or cleared only for safe sightlines and/or to remove invasive species.
Inventory wetlands and ensure no net annual loss.
Use PACE financing
State of Wisconsin Energy Independent (EI) Community designation.
Measuring Community Energy Use
Water Protection
Community energy use strategies encourage energy efficiency and the use of renewable fuels to reduce total energy consumption
throughout the community
COMMUNITY ENERGY USE
Create community policy and BMP guidelines on minimizing chemical use during vegetation management of public and private
properties
Certification as Bird City Wisconsin Community
E
N
E
R
G
Y Develop list of lighting, HVAC and shell improvements to raise Energy Star Portfolio Manager or LEED EBO&M score
Natural resource management strategies seek to conserve, preserve, protect and promote a community’s greenspace, wildlife,
wetlands and waterways for this and future generations by promoting pervious surfaces and adequate setbacks.
Include transportation energy/emissions as criterion in RFPs for purchases of goods over $10,000.
MUNICIPAL ENERGY USE
Municipal energy use strategies encourage municipal employees to conserve energy, preserve the environment, and decrease
greenhouse gas emissions from municipal facilities, services, and vehicle fleets.
Government Energy Use Policies
I:\Planning\Sustainability Advisory Brd\2018\Meeting Packet Info\03-05-18\GTLC_Scoresheet_Filled Out Page 3 of 8
ElementMax. ScoreOshkosh
2016
Scores*
Oshkosh
2017 Goals*
Oshkosh
2018 Goals*
Sustainability Strategies Scoresheet
(Also known as Appendix 3 of GTLC Charter, Last Revised 02-08-2016 by Rick Eilertson)
6 N/A
5 CHECK
3 3
5 N/A
0
5 N/A
2 N/A
10 N/A
6 N/A
4 N/A
2 N/A
6 N/A
3 N/A
5 N/A
2 ?
3 N/A
4 N/A
10 N/A?
5 ?
1 1
5 N/A?
Stoplights are LED or functional equivalent
Provide transit passes at 50 percent or more off the regular price and/or provide parking cash-out options for local government
employees.
Streetlights operate at 75 lumens/Watt or higher
Local Government Use
Develop a water loss control plan with targets below the 15% required by the state and include a system-wide water audit
implementation and time table
Infiltration and inflow reduction by 10%
Develop a water efficiency and conservation plan for municipal buildings
WATER USE CONSERVATION
Water Conservation strategy options set baselines and goals for water and energy performance in municipalities. They measure
progress and promote water conservation by the government, business, and the community at-large.
Plan for replacing all toilets using > 1.6 gpf and annual progress sufficient to reach 90 percent replacement in 10 years.
WATER AND WASTEWATER INFRASTRUCTURE MANAGEMENT
Setting goals for the sustainable management of water and wastewater infrastructure reduces costs; saves energy; and ensures the
protection of public health and the environment.
Develop and implement asset management plans that set targets for the sustainable maintenance, operation and renewal of water
and wastewater infrastructure.
E
N
E
R
G
Y
W
A
T
E
R
Join EPA's WaterSense Program for water utilities or the Groundwater Guardian Green Sites program and promote them to local
business.
Use block rates and flat rates to encourage water conservation among residential, commercial, and industrial users.
Install waterless urinals in men's restrooms at municipal facilities (city hall, parks, etc.)
All outdoor watering by local government, excluding parks and golf courses, from rain collection.
Water Conservation
Calculate annual government fleet use of motor fuels, in gallons of petroleum and biofuels, beginning with the fifth year before
entering the program.
Municipal electricity purchases are at least 5 percentage points higher in renewable content than the statewide renewable portfolio
standard requires. Calculation may include self-generated power and purchased offsets.
Measuring Government Energy Use
Complete EPA Energy Star Portfolio Manager spreadsheet for government energy use. Or score existing buildings with LEED EBO&M.
All new and renovated municipal buildings must meet LEED Silver or greater.
Track water and sewer use annually, beginning with fifth year before entering program, and develop plan for reductions.
Set goals for increasing the recovery of resources from wastewater for energy generation (heat or electricity) and fertilizer.
Wastewater biogas captured and used in operations.
Financial assistance for sewer lateral replacements.
I:\Planning\Sustainability Advisory Brd\2018\Meeting Packet Info\03-05-18\GTLC_Scoresheet_Filled Out Page 4 of 8
ElementMax. ScoreOshkosh
2016
Scores*
Oshkosh
2017 Goals*
Oshkosh
2018 Goals*
Sustainability Strategies Scoresheet
(Also known as Appendix 3 of GTLC Charter, Last Revised 02-08-2016 by Rick Eilertson)
2 2
6 ?
3 3
3 3
2 2
2 2
5 N/A
0
6 6
3 N/A
4 N/A
3 N/A
4 N/A
3 N/A
3 3
5 5
3 N/A
4 4
3 N/A
Replace concrete channels with re-meandered and naturalized creeks, wetlands, or swales
Develop a regular street sweeping program to reduce total suspended solids
Work with commercial or light industrial businesses to develop stormwater pollution plans
Inventory all paved surfaces (e.g., by GIS mapping), and develop a plan for reduction
WATER AND DEVELOPMENT
Waters, Wetlands, and Wildlife
Provide incentives for protection of green infrastructure, sensitive areas, important wildlife habitat, or for the restoration or
rehabilitation of wetlands or other degraded habitats such as credit towards open space or set-aside requirements
Construction/deconstruction waste recycling ordinance
WASTE MANAGEMENT AND REDUCTION
Identify key green infrastructure areas during plan development and/or implement a plan to acquire and protect key green
infrastructure areas
Land Development
Develop a system for identifying culverts that obstruct fish migration and install fish friendly culverts where needed
Water and Development strategy options link water conservation and the preservation of land, wetlands, and wildlife habitat while
promoting compact development, restoration and rehabilitation efforts, and long-term planning.
W
A
T
E
R
W
A
S
T
E
Waste Management and Reduction strategy options encourage municipalities and their citizens to divert organics and recyclables
from landfills and properly dispose of hazardous materials in an effort to reduce waste in a community.
Waste and materials management plan based on "zero-waste" principles, with specific goals, prepared and updated annually
Develop a municipal collection program that encourages the diversion of food discards, yard materials, and other organics from
landfills to composting or anaerobic digestion with energy recovery
Develop and promote programs that dispose of household hazardous, medical, and electronic waste
Use anaerobic digesters to process organic waste and produce energy
Implement municipal ordinances requiring manufacturer takeback for fluorescent bulbs, thermostats and other mercury-containing
devices
Mandatory residential curbside recycling pickup that covers paper, metal cans, glass and plastic bottles
Stormwater utility fees offer credits for best management practices such as rain barrels, rain gardens, and pervious paving
Community waste stream monitored at least annually . Waste reduction plan prepared and updated annually
STORMWATER MANAGEMENT
Stormwater Management strategy options encourage the use of best management practices to achieve a reduction in the amount of
harmful pollutants introduced to our streams, rivers, and lakes.
Explore partnership options with high-strength waste.
Upgrade water and wastewater utility equipment (e.g., variable frequency drive motors) to achieve energy efficiency based on total
life cycle, triple bottom line costs (e.g. maintenance and replacement strategies in asset management plans).
I:\Planning\Sustainability Advisory Brd\2018\Meeting Packet Info\03-05-18\GTLC_Scoresheet_Filled Out Page 5 of 8
ElementMax. ScoreOshkosh
2016
Scores*
Oshkosh
2017 Goals*
Oshkosh
2018 Goals*
Sustainability Strategies Scoresheet
(Also known as Appendix 3 of GTLC Charter, Last Revised 02-08-2016 by Rick Eilertson)
2 N/A
2 2
1 1
5 N/A
8 N/A
8
8
3 N/A
5 5
6
6
7 N/A
4 4
4 4
3 N/A
7 7H
E
A
L
T
H
Planning
Healthy Food Access
Physical Activity and Access
Implement strategies (urban agriculture, community gardens on public land, diversified farmer’s markets, expanded
traditional retail food options, ordinances to allow urban chickens and beekeeping and vegetable gardening in rights of
way) that help increase fresh food access in the community, in particular in areas with food insecurity (e.g., “food
deserts” and “food swamps”), including access by EBT and WIC participants.
Create a Food Systems Plan that addresses the production, distribution, value-added, marketing, end-market, and disposal of food,
and charge a new or existing governmental body to oversee the plan’s implementation.
Provide an on-street and/or off-street trail network connecting recreational areas in the community (e.g. safe routes to parks) and
other trip generators, such as shopping malls, ensuring all neighborhoods are included in planning and implementation.
Encourage pedestrian and bicycle site connections from front door of businesses or apartments to a public sidewalk and/or bike
lane ensuring connections to all neighborhoods.
Provide education and establish programming to encourage physical activity, especially by youth.
Establish an expanded public transit that serves commuters from all neighborhoods and major parks and recreation facilities, and has
racks on vehicles for carrying bicycles.
Policies Affecting Multiple Program Areas
Adopt a resolution that promotes Health in All Policies at the community level (e.g., HEAL Resolution). Include that educational
campaigns supporting a program covered by the resolution are appropriately targeted to all of the populations addressed by the
program
Establish a Health Impact Assessments policy, including when an assessment is required and its scope
Add health policies in 1 or more of the community's plans, including the comprehensive plan, long-range transportation plan,
bicycle/pedestrian plan and open spaces recreation plan (embedded or stand-alone chapter) or develop a comprehensive,
community wide wellness plan.
Site schools in the Comprehensive Plan for accessibility with existing or new bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure
Encourage the formation and/or support of Neighborhood Improvement Districts (NIDs), Neighborhood Development Corporations,
or other similar types of neighborhood reinvestment and enhancement strategies in plans or policies.
W
A
S
T
E
Pay-as-you-throw system implemented by municipality or required of private waste haulers
Ordinances in place to reduce the usage of phone books as well as single-use shopping bags, styrofoam food containers and other
disposable packaging
HEALTHY COMMUNITY PLANNING
Policies and projects related to incorporating health living into community design- whether by built form, programs, education, etc. in
an effort to reduce trends in poor nutrition, inactive lifestyles, chronic diseases, such as obesity and heart disease, and other negative
health risk factors.
Use public education and outreach to promote recycling, backyard composting, product re-use and waste reduction
I:\Planning\Sustainability Advisory Brd\2018\Meeting Packet Info\03-05-18\GTLC_Scoresheet_Filled Out Page 6 of 8
ElementMax. ScoreOshkosh
2016
Scores*
Oshkosh
2017 Goals*
Oshkosh
2018 Goals*
Sustainability Strategies Scoresheet
(Also known as Appendix 3 of GTLC Charter, Last Revised 02-08-2016 by Rick Eilertson)
6 6
8 8
5 5
3 3
7 7
6 6
8 8
7 N/A
6 6
5 5
4 N/A
3 N/A
7
N/A
0
2 2
5 5
6 6
5 5
8 8
Waste Pharmaceuticals
H
E
A
L
T
H Housing
Crime Prevention and Other Harm Reduction
Employee Health
Placemaking
Create and implement a climate change action plan that includes a carbon footprint study, and health related components on
reducing air pollution from combustion of fossil fuels and responding to heat episodes and flooding, focusing in particular on most
vulnerable populations.
Adopt an ordinance, including conditional use permits, on noise abatement for various zoning districts.
Implement a wellness program for employees of the local jurisdiction.
Encourage or partner with others, such as the Chamber of Commerce, etc., to advance workplace wellness programs within the
community.
Support placemaking at varying scale (neighborhood to major city facility) and permanence (temporary to permanent) through
programming, financial support and removal of regulatory barriers to promote healthy living and social capital in the community.
Adopt form-based codes or similar type design guidelines for healthy active living environments.
Establish a program to make housing more affordable.
Establish a program to address chronic homelessness, such as "permanent housing".
Use by policy, ordinance or practice, Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design and active threat planning to make public
spaces, such as recreational space, crime free.
Establish and implement Harm Reduction strategies for alcohol outlet density and sexual oriented establishments (e.g. zoning
limitations)
Adopt an ordinance or policy that requires tobacco-free and e-cigarette free apartments or places limitations on such structures.
Adopt an ordinance or policy that promotes tobacco-free and e-cigarette free parks and/or public events on local government-
owned property.
Climate Change
Noise
Require sidewalks in new residential areas and establish a policy for adding sidewalks, as appropriate, in areas built out without
sidewalks.
Implement a Complete Streets policy.
Provide recreation programs for youth, adults, senior citizens and disabled persons.
Establish a pedestrian safety task force.
Adopt ordinances and programs to maintain a healthy housing stock (code enforcement, landlord licenses, volunteer program, truth-
in housing disclosure before sale, etc.).
Allow life cycle or adaptable housing options, such as "aging in place", accessory dwelling units, Universal or Inclusive Design,
Dementia Friendly Communities, Age-Friendly Communities, etc.
I:\Planning\Sustainability Advisory Brd\2018\Meeting Packet Info\03-05-18\GTLC_Scoresheet_Filled Out Page 7 of 8
ElementMax. ScoreOshkosh
2016
Scores*
Oshkosh
2017 Goals*
Oshkosh
2018 Goals*
Sustainability Strategies Scoresheet
(Also known as Appendix 3 of GTLC Charter, Last Revised 02-08-2016 by Rick Eilertson)
4 4
536 229
43%
HEALTH
Establish partnerships to reduce waste pharmaceuticals generated in the community and to efficiently collect remaining wastes to
prevent their abuse and entry into solid waste or wastewater.
I:\Planning\Sustainability Advisory Brd\2018\Meeting Packet Info\03-05-18\GTLC_Scoresheet_Filled Out Page 8 of 8