HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES_04-06-17 Minutes of the April 6,2017 Board Meeting
1,
1 11 j c it
(Approved at the May 4,2017 Board Meeting.)
1"('(wt r - r crri nr?rt_ - I '�J irn
The April meeting of the Oshkosh Public Museum Board was held on Thursday, April 6, 2017, in
the Library of the Oshkosh Public Museum. President Rego called the meeting to order at 4:00
pm.
The roll was taken by Ms. Books.
Present: Present: Excused:
Mr. Randy Domer Mr. Gabe Loiacono, Alternate Ms. Allison Garner,
Ms. Diana Drew, Secretary Ms. Becky Matzke School Board President
Ms. Connie Drexler, Alternate Mr. Rick Rego, President Ms. Maribeth Theusch,
Ms. Carol Fenrich Ms.Jean Thierman Leadership Oshkosh
Mr.Jim Hoffman,Vice President Mr. Stan Mack, Superintendent of Schools
arrived at 4:10.
Also in attendance: Director Brad Larson, Auxiliary Treasurer Nancy Samida, City Planner
Elizabeth Williams, Architect Alexandra Ramsey, and Administrative Assistant Theresa Books
recording the minutes.
Mr. Larson introduced Architect Alexandra Ramsey of Engberg Anderson Architects. Ms.
Ramsey presented three conceptual ideas for the new entrance. She highlighted the best features
from each, which she had talked through with Museum staff prior to the Board meeting. The new
entrance must enhance the visitor experience, add ADA compliance to the Museum by adding
restrooms on the main level and making the space easier to maneuver for visitors using
wheelchairs and families with strollers. In addition, the new space is to provide safety for the
staff by including a freight elevator;eliminating the need to hoist crates up stairs.
Ms. Williams and Ms. Ramsey excused themselves after the presentation.
Consent Agenda items included the following:
A. Minutes of the March Board meeting
B. April Bill List
Ms. Thierman moved that the Consent Agenda be approved.
Second by Mr. Domer.
The vote went as follows:
In Favor: In Favor: Against:
Mr. Domer Mr. Mack None
Ms. Drew Ms. Matzke
Ms. Fenrich Mr. Rego
Mr. Hoffman Ms. Thierman
The vote was unanimous in favor and the Consent Agenda items were passed.
Minutes of the April 2017 Museum Board Meeting
Oshkosh Public Museum■ 1331 Algoma Boulevard■Oshkosh,Wisconsin 54901
Page 1 of 6
Next on the agenda was discussion regarding costs for buses for field trips o the Museum. Ms.
Drew began with a statement and a table of bus costs for each Oshkosh school.
Ms. Drew began by noting that when the Oshkosh Public Museum first began its search for a
new main floor exhibit, the staff received input from different groups within the community.
Many ideas were received from the Oshkosh Area School District teachers and ultimately the
decision was made to design an exhibit that coordinates with the fourth grade curriculum, which
in part addresses Wisconsin Act 31.
The Museum has undertaken this project with an outlay of $750,000. Moreover, the project
involves staff planning, research, readying the exhibit area, supportive curriculum, and the
generous time given by Dr. Jeffrey Behm authenticating artifacts so that the information
presented is accurate.
Ms. Drew expressed that when People of the Waters was first discussed she asked Superintendent
Mack if the school district would support this exhibit by bringing the 4th grade students to the
museum. He responded that this was not within the budget of the Oshkosh Area School District.
Ms. Drew then noted, in Brad's memo dated February 10, 2017, he mentioned speaking with a
teacher in Appleton about Museum field trips. She indicated that money for transportation was
their biggest hurdle. Brad also stated that this was a concern of Oshkosh teachers. At a prior
meeting Barb Shirtz mentioned perhaps raising money for field trips could be a special project of
the Auxiliary.
Because Ms. Drew wondered just how expensive museum field trips were, she researched costs
and contacted the Transportation Department of the Oshkosh Area Schools. She presented a
spreadsheet showing the flat rate for the bus is $47.61. The spreadsheet also includes mileage
from Kobussen to each school in round trip figures, mileage from the schools to the museum in
round trip figures, and total mileage which is calculated at a rate of $1.29 per mile. The total
comes to $868.41 annually for all 4th grade groups to travel to the Museum. She stated that this
was not an exorbitant amount in comparison to the money expended by the Museum.
Stating that she did not look at trips to the Museum to attend this exhibit as a classic "field trip,"
but rather a curriculum based supported field study. Therefore, Ms. Drew said they should be
supported by the Oshkosh Area School District, realizing that these costs cannot be absorbed by
the individual schools because we have schools like Traeger that could raise the money but it is
unlikely that Washington would be able to do the same.
In conclusion, she expressed the opinion that the Oshkosh Public Museum should not look
beyond its current investment for People of the Waters to consider funding these trips. Should the
Museum commit to such funding, it would be setting a precedent; one she feels should not be
entered into. Instead, her hope is that there would be other sources of revenue to cover the costs
for field trips. In summary Ms. Drew noted she wants all the children to be able to attend the
People of the Waters exhibition.
Minutes of the April 2017 Museum Board Meeting
Oshkosh Public Museum■ 1331 Algoma Boulevard■Oshkosh,Wisconsin 54901
Page 2 of 6
Discussion followed. Ms. Fenrich suggested writing letters to PTOs to request their help. Mr.
Loiacono agreed that his experience on PTOs shows that they want to respond to the needs that
teachers bring to them. There was concern that some schools just don't have the means to raise
funds, even through the PTOs. Mr. Rego recommended checking with other community
organizations that may help, such as Kiwanis. Ms. Drexler proposed checking with the Oshkosh
Area Community Foundation (OACF) to see what funds might already be set up, that would be
appropriate for this need. Board members liked the idea to check with this community resource.
Mr. Domer proposed that since there seems to be agreement to checking with the OACF, who
should meet with Mr. Wyman at the OACF? Mr. Mack stated he will first check with his
curriculum staff regarding plans for trips to the Museum and budgets to cover those trips.
The next item was discussion and vote on using $450 in Collections Fund earnings for the
purchase of reproduction Native American Trade Silver for People of the Waters; and $700 for
radio carbon dating of a possible prehistoric bow, also for People of the Waters.
Ms. Fenrich moved that the Board approve use of $450 in Collections Fund earnings for the
purchase of reproduction Native American Trade Silver for People of the Waters; and $700 for
radio carbon dating of a possible prehistoric bow, also for People of the Waters.
Second by Ms. Drew.
The vote went as follows:
In Favor: In Favor: Against:
Mr. Domer Mr. Mack None
Ms. Drew Ms. Matzke
Ms. Fenrich Mr. Rego
Mr. Hoffman Ms. Thierman
The vote was unanimous in favor and the motion passed.
Mr. Rego then requested that Mr. Larson present the Director's Report.
Mr. Larson began his report updating the Board on People of the Waters. He noted that about two
months remain before Split Rock Studios begins installation. Split Rock Studios is scheduled to
begin installation on June 9 and complete the task by June 30. This work is part of their overall
contract and no additional costs or fees are anticipated. On the Museum's side, there is wall prep
and painting to do, lighting must be installed, and the walk-over excavation structural elements
must be constructed. Matt Reinke is working hard to complete fit-out and as the Board has seen
over the months, is doing an awesome job. The "river' flooring is scheduled for delivery on or
about April 17 and should be installed within a month after that. A major portion of Greg
Witthun's time is devoted to artifact mounts for the immense number of objects in the timeline.
Moreover, staff will be taking over completing the dugout canoe; the canoe has been problematic
because of cracking and twisting. The canoe is the first item that must be installed in the 40-foot
long timeline.
Minutes of the April 2017 Museum Board Meeting
Oshkosh Public Museum■ 1331 Algoma Boulevard■Oshkosh,Wisconsin 54901
Page 3 of 6
Mr. Larson further noted the media component, which is one element that will make People of the
Waters stand well above an average exhibition, has taken much staff time. While all staff are
doing good work, he pointed out the extraordinary contributions of Katrina Achilli and Joan
Lloyd. Katrina continues to be the Museum's primary liaison with Split Rock and Northern
Lights, which is the media firm that Split Rock contracts with, and Joan is working diligently
with artifacts. Northern Lights is a top-rated media firm and their cutting edge work on
exhibition interactive elements is in use at major museums across the nation, including the
Smithsonian and the National World War II Museum. Mr. Larson stated,from what we have seen
with the glacial animation and the fur trade game, the firm truly understands how to engage
people with media. Once the installation is complete at the end of June, it gives staff about two
months for fine-tuning, docent and staff training, and presenting special tours and talks. The
Member premier is August 23 (5:00 to 7:00), and the public opening is September 5 (10:00 to 3:00).
Karla is working on the activities for this and her ideas and efforts have paid off nicely. A
detailed event summary will be sent to the Board. Mr. Larson pointed out that an up-to-date
budget summary of People of the Waters is included in the information packet for Board review.
The Museum and Finance Departments are requesting that the Common Council amend the 2017
Capital Improvement budget at the April 11 meeting to reflect the fit-out expenses, which are
covered by donations received in support of the project. Mr. Larson then noted that there is a
great deal of work to do on the grounds every spring. While Nancy Albright can handle some of
the annual grounds work, other tasks will have to be delayed until Mr. Reinke completes his
work in the gallery.
Mr. Larson then expressed that based on the feedback he received from Board members, it is
apparent that the next step for the Durow Trust is to look into what would be required to form or
create a foundation. If this is correct, rather than create a formal committee he will begin
discussions with Lynn Lorenson and Trena Larson on how best to proceed. Board members
agreed he should begin discussions with Ms. Lorenson and Ms. Larson.
In conclusion, Mr. Larson explained that any museum's key or principal policy is its Collections
Management Policy. This is the document that guides staff in the consistent, professional
management of collections, a core purpose. He noted the Museum's Collections Management
Policy has been periodically revised over the years and the Board has reviewed and approved
those changes. However, Mr. Larson knew it was time for a top-to- bottom review and revision
as part of the reaccreditation process and to reflect current practices. Durow Curator Anna
Cannizzo has completed the task, with input from appropriate staff, and she will do a short
presentation of the policy at an upcoming meeting. That concluded the Director's report.
Mr. Rego requested the World War I Commemoration Committee Report.
Ms. Matzke reported that the World War I Commemoration Committee met in March, with Bob
Campbell of EAA joining the Committee. Mr. Loiacono introduced two University of Wisconsin
-Oshkosh history students who reported on the research they are doing to create Oshkosh WWI
"standees." Mr. Larson met with the Parks Board, recommending Rainbow Park's name be
returned to its original name of Rainbow Memorial Park. Ms. Matzke further reported that the
Minutes of the April 2017 Museum Board Meeting
Oshkosh Public Museum■ 1331 Algoma Boulevard■Oshkosh,Wisconsin 54901
Page 4 of 6
Museum launched the web portal to WWI information. The Library is developing WWI related
events, with Ms. Matzke presenting the first lecture on April 41h, giving an overview of The Great
War. The WWI project now has a logo, designed to look similar to a war poster. Ms. Matzke was
pleased to report that the Northwestern will reprint the front page of the April 6, 1917 Northwestern
which announced the US was now at war. In conclusion, the Committee will meet again to
continue planning additional events, with the possibility of a music festival, and an Armistice
Day celebration in November 2018. That concluded the WWI Commemoration Committee
Report.
Mr. Rego then requested the Auxiliary Report.
Ms. Samida began the report stating that the recent fundraiser at Culvers was fun for all who
helped. $230.37 was raised from food purchases, tips, and a generous donation. She noted that
a Winnebago County Master Gardener will speak at the Auxiliary meeting Friday, April 7th
Additionally, Ms. Samida reported that a nominating committee will be chosen to find three
new board members in May. The annual May luncheon is at Primo's this year. The Auxiliary
Grant Committee began work on a grant through the TREG Foundation, a real estate group
foundation fund, for financial support of the annual Gala. Ms. Samida then expressed that the
Auxiliary members were honored to learn that in 2018 the Auxiliary will receive the
Partnership Award at the State of the City event. That concluded the Auxiliary Report.
With no other agenda items Mr. Rego asked for a motion to adjourn. Ms. Thierman so moved
and Mr. Hoffman seconded the motion.
The vote was unanimous in favor and the motion was passed.
The meeting adjourned at 5:20 p.m.
Minutes of the April 2017 Museum Board Meeting
Oshkosh Public Museum■ 1331 Algoma Boulevard■Oshkosh,Wisconsin 54901
Page 5 of 6
BUS COSTS FOR FIELD TRIPS TO OSHKOSH PUBLIC MUSEUM
MILEAGE
MILEAGE SCHOOL
TO TO MILEAGE TOTAL
BUS SCHOOLS MUSEUM TOTAL @$1.29 BUS RATE
SCHOOL RATE ROUND MILEAGE PER MILE PLUS
TRIP* ROUND MILEAGE
TRIP
Carl Traeger $47.61 6.4 11.2 17.6 $22.70 $70.31
Emmeline Cook $47.61 10.2 4.2 14.4 $18.58 $66.19
Franklin $47.61 6.4 4.8 11.2 $14.45 $62.06
Green
Meadow @Tipler $47.61 6.0 4.8 10.8 $13.93 $61.54
Jacob Shapiro $47.61 11.2 6.4 17.6 $22.70 $70.31
Jefferson $47.61 9.8 4.2 14.0 $18.06 $65.67
Lakeside $47.61 22.4 14 36.4 $46.96 $94.57
Merrill WALK WALK WALK WALK WALK
Oaklawn $47.61 8.6 3.4 12.0 $15.48 $63.09
Oakwood $47.61 0.6 5.4 6.0 $7.74 $55.35
Read WALK WALK WALK WALK WALK
Roosevelt $47.61 5.2 2.4 7.6 $9.80 $57.41
Smith $47.61 12.2 5.4 17.6 $22.70 $70.31
Washington $47.61 10.4 4.4 14.8 $19.09 $66.70
Webster Stanley $47.61 9.4 4 13.4 $17.29 $64.90
TOTALS $618.93 118.8 74.6 193.4 $249.48 $868.41
' THESE FIGURES OBTAINED FROM THE TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT OF THE
OSHKOSH AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT
** THESE FIGURES OBTAINED FROM GOOGLE, ALSO USED BY OASD IN MILEAGE
DETERMINATION
BUS CAPACITY IS 72 PASSENGERS
BUS TIME ALLOTTED IS 3.5 HOURS
PREPARED 3/5/17-Diana Drew
Minutes of the April 2017 Museum Board Meeting
Oshkosh Public Museum■ 1331 Algoma Boulevard■Oshkosh,Wisconsin 54901
Page 6 of 6