HomeMy WebLinkAbout07.10.2024 Minutes Landmarks CommissionCITY OF OSHKOSH LANDMARKS COMMISSION
Minutes
July 10th, 2024
PRESENT: Shirley Brabender Mattox, Sara Stichert, Paulette Feld, Nikki Stoll Olthoff, and
Vicky Redlin
ABSENT: Kristopher Ulrich, Steve Cummings, Gerald Jacklin, and Council Member Jacob
Floam
STAFF: Amy Fels, Museum Archivist and Mark Lyons, Planning Services Manager –
Community Development
Agenda:
1) Call to Order
The meeting was called to order at 3:05pm
2) Approval of June 12th Meeting Minutes
Ms. Feld motioned to approve the minutes, and Ms. Stichert seconded. The minutes
were unanimously approved by voice vote.
3) Downtown Visualization Project information presented by City Community
Development Department
Mark Lyons from the City of Oshkosh Community Development department presented
the recent Downtown Visualization Project to the commissioners. Accompanied by a
PowerPoint, Mr. Lyons explained the process by which the Downtown Visualization
Project came together. He emphasized that the project is led by a variety of community
partners and organizations with facilitating assistance from the City; it is not a City-led
initiative, which is why Boards and Commissions were not asked to be involved yet. He
walked the Commissioners through the project ideas, as well as past visualization
projects and initiatives that have been completed in the city. He explained the intent of
the visualization project is to be a high-level conceptual document that shows potential
development opportunities. The Commissioners asked questions of Mr. Lyons and
discussed other development opportunities around the city and concerns regarding
historic preservation in the face of development.
4) 413 N. Main Street Historic Plaque Application
Ms. Brabender Mattox provided an update on the historic plaque application process for
413. N. Main Street and marking it as Lewis Hine’s childhood home. She is continuing
research to ensure the building name and text on the plaque accurately reflect the
building’s history. She remains in communication with the building owners throughout
the process and is pleased with the progress. Ms. Brabender Mattox also intends to write
and submit a proclamation to the governor’s office, as she did for Helen Farnsworth
Mears.
5) Landmarks Commission Handbook Development
Due to time constraints following Mr. Lyons’ presentation and the subsequent
discussion, this item was postponed until the August meeting.
6) Potential Historic Districts on the South and West Sides
Due to time constraints following Mr. Lyons’ presentation and the subsequent
discussion, this item was postponed until the August meeting.
7) Discussion to Increase Public Education, Support re: Home Rehabilitation, Historic Tax
Credits
Due to time constraints following Mr. Lyons’ presentation and the subsequent
discussion, this item was postponed until the August meeting.
8) Future of the Pollock House on UW-Oshkosh’s Campus
Ms. Brabender Mattox contacted the Wisconsin Historical Society regarding the moving
of historic structures and received information stating that a relocation package will
need to be prepared in order for a structure to be moved appropriately and retain its
status on the National Register.
9) Commissioner Statements
a. Wisconsin Association of Historic Preservation Commission (WAHPC)
Landmarks Newsletter
Ms. Brabender Mattox asked to ensure that the Commission members were
receiving the newsletter.
b. Guild Hall, Trinity Episcopal Church
Following community discussions regarding the future of the building, Ms.
Brabender Mattox informed the Commission that enough money had been
raised to save and continue using the building.
c. Lewis Hine Working Committee
d. Merrill School
Ms. Brabender Mattox has been in contact with an historical architecture firm
involved with Merrill School. She learned that someone is documenting the
interior of the building prior to its scheduled demolition.
10) Staff Liaison Report
a. Monthly Building Permit Report
The Commissioners reviewed the monthly report. Ms. Brabender Mattox had
questions about a porch project on a home in the N. Main Street Bungalow
district that she will look into.
b. Agenda Items for Next Meeting
Items 5-7 will be moved to August.
11) Adjournment
The meeting lost quorum when two attending members had to leave around 4:30 for
other commitments. The meeting did not formally adjourn but ended at 4:48.