The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutHistoric Resources Survey Appendix A. Identified Survey Areas and Properties X:\15073-00\05001\TECH\Rpts\WPC\060530A.doc A-1 Specific areas within the city included in the survey: • Colonial Park Subdivision – Morgan Subdivision • Nordheim • North Main Street to Broad Street from Merritt Avenue to Irving Avenue • 4th Avenue to 8th Avenue from Lake Winnebago to Knapp Street • Lakeview Park Plat • Area west of Broad Street and south of Lake Winnebago • Area of early settlement bound by the Fox River, Oshkosh Avenue, and North Eagle Street • Volga-German Neighborhood • St. Josephat Neighborhood • Sacred Heart Neighborhood • Workers cottages on 6th and 7th Avenues • County Grounds, Extension Office Building • Doty Street, including the Glatz Park area • Typical post-World War II residential development • Algoma Boulevard between Wisconsin Street and Dawes Street Specific property types included in the survey: • William Waters-designed buildings not included in the 1981 survey (specific properties identified by the City) • Examples of commercial buildings with attached housing • Churches with associated structures • Kit or catalog homes (specific properties identified by the City) • Homes or buildings associated with people, business enterprises, or events, significant to the City’s history • Homes with significant interior features (specific properties identified by the City) Properties nominated by the public for inclusion in the survey: • Gustav Behncke House, 557 Mt. Vernon • Tennis Club, 823 Fluor Court • House, 1930 Mt. Vernon • Miles and Alberta Kimball House, 2346 Hickory Lane • William Waters-Designed House, 324 Fulton • House, 919 Merritt Avenue • Herman Beduhn House, 328 West 15th Avenue • Potters Cemetery Appendix B. National Register Criteria for Evaluation Appendix C. Reevaluation Results X:\15073-00\05001\TECH\Rpts\WPC\060530A.doc C-1 Oshkosh Reevaluation Properties Address Historic Name 1981 Evaluation 2005 Evaluation 138 Algoma Boulevard Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 146 Algoma Boulevard Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 504 Algoma Boulevard Read House Not eligible Not eligible 512, 516, and 520 Algoma Boulevard Apartments Not eligible Eligible 530 Algoma Boulevard Residence Not eligible Eligible 535 Algoma Boulevard Bedward House Not eligible Eligible 545 Algoma Boulevard Ripley House Eligible Eligible 554 Algoma Boulevard Wall House Not eligible Nonextant 555 Algoma Boulevard Kiel House Not eligible Not eligible 1000 Bay Shore Drive Adams House Not eligible Eligible 1124 Bay Shore Drive House Not eligible Eligible 344 Bowen Street House Not eligible Not eligible 461 Bowen Street House Not eligible Not eligible 36 Broad Street Baker Paper Co. Not eligible Not eligible 622 Ceape Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 926 Ceape Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 1723 Central Street House Not eligible Not eligible 1001-1011 Cherry Street Catalog Houses (3) Not eligible Not eligible 316 Court Street Sons of Herman Building "Unknown" Eligible 322 Court Street House Not eligible Not eligible 1551 Delaware Street South Park Jr. High School Not eligible Not eligible 420 Division Street Gas Station No AHI Record Eligible 425 Division Street Oshkosh Public Schools Municipal Building Not eligible Eligible 1650 Doty Street Horn House Not eligible Eligible 1707 Doty Street House Not eligible Not eligible X:\15073-00\05001\TECH\Rpts\WPC\060530A.doc C-2 Oshkosh Reevaluation Properties Address Historic Name 1981 Evaluation 2005 Evaluation 1757 Doty Street Schneider House Not eligible Not eligible 41 West 8th Avenue Miles Kimball Company Not eligible Not eligible 123 West 8th Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 816 Elmwood Avenue House Not eligible Eligible 1115 Elmwood Avenue Rogers House Not eligible Eligible – within Elmwood Avenue Historic District 331 West 15th Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 512 West 14th Avenue Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 622 West 4th Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 705 Grove Street House Not eligible Eligible 24 Gruenwald Avenue Jockey Club Not eligible Not eligible 221 High Avenue Hannig House Not eligible Not eligible 102 East Irving Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 222 East Irving Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 623 East Irving Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 1014 East Irving Avenue Mertz House Not eligible Eligible 731 Jackson Street St. Paul’s Episcopal Not eligible Not eligible 734 Jackson Street House Not eligible Not eligible 920 Jackson Street Barnes House Not eligible Not eligible 1702 Jackson Street House Not eligible Nonextant 448 Jefferson Street Apartments Not eligible Eligible 756 Jefferson Street House Not eligible Not eligible 1639 Knapp Street House Not eligible Eligible 6 Lake Street Buckstaff House Not eligible Not eligible 336 Legion Place House Not eligible Not eligible 313 East Lincoln Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible X:\15073-00\05001\TECH\Rpts\WPC\060530A.doc C-3 Oshkosh Reevaluation Properties Address Historic Name 1981 Evaluation 2005 Evaluation 712, 714 West Lincoln Avenue Identical frame houses Not eligible Not eligible 538 Madison Street House Not eligible Eligible 202 North Main Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 206 North Main Street Commercial – Waters design Not eligible Not eligible 220 North Main Street Kline's Department Store Not eligible Not eligible 656 North Main Street W. Suhl Block Not eligible Not eligible 663 North Main Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 688-690 North Main Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 752 North Main Street Oshkosh Cleaners and Dryers Not eligible Not eligible 2119 North Main Street Buckstaff Observatory National Register-listed National Register- listed 610 South Main Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 901-905 South Main Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 907 South Main Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 909-913 South Main Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 920 South Main Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 1127 South Main Street Buckstaff Company Offices Not eligible Eligible – Entire complex considered eligible 1503 South Main Street Standard Gas Station Not eligible Not eligible 1512 South Main Street People's Brewing Company Not eligible Not eligible 701 Merritt Street Commercial Not eligible Eligible 1306 Michigan Street German Emmanuel Evangelical Church Not eligible Not eligible 1013 Minnesota Street Church Not eligible Not eligible 1103 Minnesota Street Second Methodist Episcopal Church Not eligible Not eligible 439 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Nonextant 453 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Not eligible X:\15073-00\05001\TECH\Rpts\WPC\060530A.doc C-4 Oshkosh Reevaluation Properties Address Historic Name 1981 Evaluation 2005 Evaluation 456 Mt. Vernon Street Doe House Eligible Not eligible 463 Mt. Vernon Street Campbell House Eligible Not eligible 521 Mt. Vernon Street Provost House Eligible Not eligible 533 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Not eligible 538 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Eligible 564 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Not eligible 618 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Eligible 740 Mt. Vernon Street Kleinschmidt House Eligible Eligible 803 Mt. Vernon Street Barker House Eligible Not eligible 1036 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Not eligible 1102 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Not eligible 1402 Mt. Vernon Street Industrial Building Not eligible Not eligible 1721 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Not eligible 1838 Mt. Vernon Street House Not eligible Not eligible 403 East New York Avenue Church Not eligible Not eligible 21 West New York Avenue Fire Station No. 8 Not eligible Not eligible 26 West New York Avenue House Eligible Not eligible 32 West New York Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 103 West New York Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 660 Oak Street Lakeside Hospital Not eligible Not eligible 716 Ohio Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 924 Ohio Street Fire Station No. 6 Not eligible Not eligible 600-602 Oregon Street C. Lehmann Block Not eligible Not eligible 611-619 Oregon Street C.F. Streich Block Not eligible Not eligible 701 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible X:\15073-00\05001\TECH\Rpts\WPC\060530A.doc C-5 Oshkosh Reevaluation Properties Address Historic Name 1981 Evaluation 2005 Evaluation 711 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 800 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 801 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 802 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 819 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 903 Oregon Street Security Bank Not eligible National Register - listed 907 Oregon Street Oregon Clothing House Not eligible Not eligible 909 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 910-914 Oregon Street J. Huhn Block Not eligible Not eligible 1018 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 1025 Oregon Street Marquardt Funeral Home Not eligible Not eligible 1113 Oregon Street Neff/Mehlmann House Not eligible Not eligible 1329 Oregon Street Commercial (A. Koplitz) Not eligible Not eligible 1429 Oregon Street C.W. Woldt Building Not eligible Not eligible 1512-1514 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 1529 Oregon Street Commercial (A. Karcus) Not eligible Not eligible 1628 Oregon Street House Not eligible Eligible 1645 Oregon Street House Not eligible Not eligible 1701 Oregon Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 1745 Oregon Street Smith School (William Waters design) Eligible Eligible 1856 Oregon Street Pfeiffer House Not eligible Eligible 1619 Oshkosh Avenue Coles Bashford House Eligible Not eligible 1705 Oshkosh Avenue Badger House Not eligible Eligible 406 Otter Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 521 Otter Avenue Labudde House Not eligible Not eligible 524 Otter Avenue Crawford House Not eligible Not eligible X:\15073-00\05001\TECH\Rpts\WPC\060530A.doc C-6 Oshkosh Reevaluation Properties Address Historic Name 1981 Evaluation 2005 Evaluation 208 Oxford Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 219 Oxford Avenue Ragon Cottage Eligible Not eligible 527-531 East Parkway Avenue Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 223 West Parkway Avenue Evangelical Lutheran Church Eligible Not eligible 555-557 Pleasant Street Kitts House - Octagon Eligible Not eligible 221 Prospect Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 843 Prospect Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 320 Rosalia Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 400 Sawyer Street Zion Lutheran Church Not eligible Eligible – upon reaching 50 years of age - constructed in 1969 910 Sawyer Street Roosevelt School Not eligible Eligible 514 Scott Avenue House Not eligible Not eligible 208 East Smith Avenue School Not eligible Not eligible 206 State Street P. Charbonneau Block Not eligible Not eligible 300-302 State Street Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 901 West 10th Avenue Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 117 West 12th Street House Not eligible Not eligible 848 Vine Street House Not eligible Not eligible 1819 Vinland House Not eligible Not eligible 2075 Vinland House Not eligible Not eligible 105 Washington Avenue Frateral Reserve Association Not eligible Eligible – Included in Washington Avenue Historic District 115 Washington Avenue Commercial Not eligible Eligible – Included in Washington Avenue Historic District X:\15073-00\05001\TECH\Rpts\WPC\060530A.doc C-7 Oshkosh Reevaluation Properties Address Historic Name 1981 Evaluation 2005 Evaluation 204 Washington Avenue Oshkosh Masonic Temple Not eligible Eligible – Included in Washington Avenue Historic District 219 Washington Avenue U.S. Post Office Not eligible Eligible – Included in Washington Avenue Historic District 309 Washington Avenue Apartments Not eligible Eligible 414 Washington Avenue Apartments Not eligible Not eligible 549 Washington Avenue Salem Church of the Evangelical Association Not eligible Eligible 11 Waugoo Avenue Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 13 Waugoo Avenue Commercial Not eligible Not eligible 17-25 Waugoo Avenue Center-Kohlman Block Not eligible Not eligible * Although identified by the City, 608 Jackson Street was not reevaluated since it is included within a National Register-listed historic district.